Skip to content

Mystery Files

2026 Mysteries · 13 episodes · Jan 22, 2026

  1. Mystery Files season 5 episode 1 still

    Episode 1

    The Icy Horrors of Dyatlov Pass

    Jan 22, 2026

    Shane and Ryan are returning to the bunker to visit the snowy summits of Dyatlov Pass.

  2. Mystery Files season 5 episode 2 still

    Episode 2

    The Tragic Tale of the Pollock Twins

    Feb 19, 2026

    Shane takes a walk in someone else's shoes...

  3. Mystery Files season 5 episode 3 still

    Episode 3

    The UFO Encounter in Rendlesham Forest

    Mar 19, 2026

    What mysterious forces did the US Airforce stumble upon within the thicket of Rendlesham Forest? Ryan and Shane review firsthand encounters and receive one of their own...

  4. Mystery Files season 5 episode 4 still

    Episode 4

    The Zany Details of the Dekooning Art Heist

    Apr 16, 2026

    Shane and Ryan immerse themselves in the wild misadventures of the Dekooning art heist.

  5. Mystery Files season 5 episode 5 still

    Episode 5

    The Strange Disappearance of Craig Williamson

    May 21, 2026

    The boys investigate the bizarre missing persons case of Craig Williamson.

  6. Mystery Files season 5 episode 6 still

    Episode 6

    What Led to the Bizarre Disappearance of the Franklin Expedition?

    Jun 18, 2026

    Shane and Ryan set sail on the mysterious tides of the Franklin Expedition!

  7. Mystery Files season 5 episode 7 still

    Episode 7

    Did the Atlantic Ocean Swallow Theodosia Burr Alston?

    Jul 16, 2026

    What happened to Theodosia Burr Alston? Did she perish aboard The Patriot? Find a new land to escape her titles? Join the boys in the basement as they try to untangle the mystery surrounding the tragic disappearance of Aaron Burr's beloved daughter.

  8. Mystery Files season 5 episode 8 still

    Episode 8

    The Shadow Organization Hiding UFOs

    Aug 20, 2026

    The boys revisit the mystery behind the men in black (not the Will Smith one) and Shane makes a fun little ditty in its honor.

  9. Mystery Files season 5 episode 9 still

    Episode 9

    Why Aliens Keep Abducting Cows

    Jul 23, 2026

    Aliens keep abducting cows AND WE WANNA KNOW WHY! Join us in the bunker as we try to get to the bottom of this mystery sponsored by @gonnaneedmilk

  10. Mystery Files season 5 episode 10 still

    Episode 10

    The Quest for the Fountain of Youth

    Sep 17, 2026

    Join the boys in the basement as they unravel the centuries long obsession with man's quest to find the mysterious Fountain of Youth.

  11. Mystery Files season 5 episode 11 still

    Episode 11

    The Unsettling Mystery of the House That Bleeds

    Oct 15, 2026

    The bizarre case of the Atlanta Bloodhouse sure goes down a lot better with a nice drink in hand. As the boys puzzle out the gory details, they're joined by Ricky Wang!

  12. Episode 12

    The Generations-Long Hunt for Oak Island's Buried Treasure

    Nov 19, 2026

    Uncover the mystery of Oak Island's buried treasure!

  13. Mystery Files season 5 episode 13 still

    Episode 13

    The Beatles Conspiracy Theory: Did Paul McCartney Die in 1966?

    Oct 22, 2026

    Join Ryan and Shane in the bunker as they dive into the bizarre breadcrumbs left by the Beatles that spawned the infamous conspiracy theory "Paul is Dead". This episode explores the parallels behind their potentially replaced band member and the central themes of Hulu's new show Phony in which the protagonist believes his mother has been replaced.